How Safe Are All-Season Tires in Winter?

How Safe Are All-Season Tires in Winter?

As drivers, we rely on our tires to provide the necessary grip and control during harsh weather. One common tire option for year-round driving is the all-season tire. But the burning question is: How safe are all-season tires in winter?

All-season tires are designed to provide decent performance in a variety of conditions – dry roads, wet pavement, and light snow up to 3 inches. The tread rubber and patterns used are engineered to adapt to these various scenarios.

But in trying to handle many different road conditions, all-season tires make compromises. 

It is advised that drivers in regions with moderate winters may find all-season tires suitable, as they offer good tread life, and a smooth ride, and perform well in wet and light winter driving conditions. However, in areas with colder temperatures and frequent snow and ice, the use of winter tires is highly recommended.

They aim to provide adequate traction across differing situations, but master none. And their deficiencies become apparent when they encounter heavy winter conditions beyond their intended range.

How all-season tires fall short in severe winter

car skidding in snow

Multiple independent studies have tested all-season tires against winter tires in cold, snowy conditions:

Traction and braking

snow traction score
Snow traction score: Credits: Consumer reports.

Research by the University of Michigan found that all-season tires start losing traction even on dry roads once temperatures drop below 7°C. This leads to longer stopping distances as the tread rubber hardens and loses grip. 

According to testing by the Traffic Injury Research Foundation, all-season tires needed up to 50% longer braking distances compared to winter tires on packed snow.

Handling and control

All-season tires also struggled to maintain traction and control while cornering at high speeds on snow-covered roads. In contrast, winter tires provided significantly better grip and handling in the same conditions per Consumer Reports testing. 

As tread depth on all-season tires decreases over time and with wear, wet weather, and snow traction are further reduced. This escalates the risks and hazards.

Heavy snow performance


While all-season tires may get by reasonably well in light snow of 1-3 inches, their limitations become obvious in heavy snowfalls of 4+ inches. The deep snow significantly degrades all-season tires’ traction, braking, and handling capabilities according to research by the Traffic Injury Research Foundation.

Specialized winter tires excel in snow and ice

winter tire-transformed

Unlike all seasons, winter tires are engineered specifically for use in cold, snowy, and icy conditions. The tread rubber compounds stay pliable and flexible at temperatures below 7°C to maintain a grip on ice and packed snow.

Winter tires also have aggressive block and siping tread patterns designed to channel away slush and water. 

Consumer Reports testing showed that winter tires provided up to 30% shorter stopping distances on just cold dry pavement compared to all seasons.

More dramatically, winter tires delivered 35-50% shorter braking distances on packed snow based on data from the Traffic Injury Research Foundation. 

Winter tires also provided superior high-speed handling and cornering traction on snow-covered and icy roads. 

And unlike all seasons, winter tires sustained consistent traction and performance even as tread depth wore down over time.

Knowing when to use all-seasons or winter tires

all season tire vs snow tires comparison

During warmer months, all-season tires provide adequate traction and handling for most drivers. They can also work reasonably well for areas that only receive light winter weather with occasional snowfalls under 3 inches.

If purchasing all-season tires for now:

  • Opt for tires with deeper tread depth to help maintain snow traction as they wear.
  • Look for “severe snow” rated all seasons with more aggressive tread patterns if you receive occasional heavy snowstorms.
  • Install on all four wheels for balanced handling – don’t mix with summer or winter tires.
  • Inspect tread depth regularly and replace once near 4/32 inches.
  • Reduce speed and increase the following distance when driving in snow or ice.
  • Avoid driving in heavy snowfalls of 4+ inches.

But for regions that experience sustained cold and consistent heavy snowfall over 4 inches, all-season tires pose increased risks. Drivers in these colder climates with regular heavy winter weather should install winter tires once temperatures start dropping below 7°C consistently.

The better snow and ice traction will provide much safer performance for daily commuting and travel during the winter months. Switch back to all seasons once winter has passed and temperatures are reliably above 7°C again.

Play it safe with proper winter tires

Using all-season tires in heavy snow and ice poses substantially higher safety risks due to reduced traction, braking, and control capabilities.  Switching to tires specifically engineered for winter conditions greatly improves driving safety and accident avoidance.

Consumer experts recommend installing dedicated winter tires once temperatures start consistently dropping below 7°C in your region. Exercise extra caution and reduce speeds if driving on all-season tires, and avoid going out at all in heavy snow. 

For optimal safety and performance in icy and snowy conditions, invest in a set of tires made for the job. Don’t take chances in severe winter weather – equip your ride for the conditions and reach your destination safely.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *